What's new
  • If you don't frequent the chat forum, make sure you read this post regarding land usage. It would be great if we could get everybody to send a comment in before Oct 7th!

Key or Fob?

Do you like a key or a fob better?

  • Key

    Votes: 22 81.5%
  • Fob

    Votes: 5 18.5%

  • Total voters
    27

Yinzer Moto

Well-known member
ADV+
Joined
Jan 25, 2022
Member Number
4
Posts
2,783
Location
Pittsburgh
I would like some type of fob on the scooter. Making deliveries, I remove the key at maybe 50% of the stops. It is just another step that gets old after a while.
 

kickstandsup

Why not?
ADV+
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
284
Posts
523
Location
Tucson, AZ
Key.

This whole keyless thing, car and bike, is a solution in search of a problem. Why carry a fob in your pocket that is bigger than the key?

The only solution that really makes sense to me, if you want to move away from a key, is the "credit card" key with a proximity sensor carried in your wallet.

Fobs are needless bulk.
 

kickstandsup

Why not?
ADV+
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
284
Posts
523
Location
Tucson, AZ
Another small PITA with the keyless system, at least on a Ducati MTS, is that unlike BMW, the luggage is only locked when closed. You cannot latch it closed without it also being locked.

Have to dig out the fob every time you need to open the side cases/top box. Small point, but a dumb, poorly thought out design.

None of my current bikes have a fob. When I take the key out, it gets clipped to an S-Biner that lives on my jacket. No muss, no fuss.



IMG_20220329_141447540.jpg
 

Captain Jim

Shiftless
Joined
Apr 3, 2022
Member Number
1041
Posts
130
Location
Tropical Tip of Texas
My wife's Xmax has the keyless fob - love it! She wasn't sold on it at first, but quickly learned the advantages; just put the key in your pocket, and you have access to all the things you'd normally need a key for: starting the bike, getting under the seat, opening the fuel filler door. You never have to mess with the key during your ride. I find it VERY handy.

I wish my Vespa (has a fob, but only opens the seat) and motorcycle had keyless.
 

Hank.SD

Flatlander
Joined
Feb 9, 2022
Member Number
465
Posts
13
Location
SoDak
I like the simplicity of a key and the fact that there is no question where it is. My wife and I do this routine where we drive to the store together, I let her out, and she walks off with the fob in her purse.
One of our cars just lets it happen, the other starts chirping at us and she has to come back, dig the key out of her purse, coat, shoe, bonnet, or where ever its currently hidden and hand it to me, while we're blocking traffic.

When my cars are in the garage, I tend to leave the key or fob in them. With the fob vehicles, sometimes it was in my pocket, and it went into the house with me by accident, so next day, shit, no fob as I'm trying to leave for work.

I'm in the "solution to a problem that doesn't exist, or more like creates a new problem that never existed" camp.
 

klaviator

Scooter Trash
ADV+
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
431
Posts
1,396
Location
Alabama
I like the convenience of a FOB but not the extra complexity and potential for things to go wrong. What really bugs me is that unlike cars, some bikes come with only one FOB and getting a second one is expensive.
 

Fidget

Skeptical
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
94
Posts
12
Location
Napa, Ca
Bike fob is handy. I leave it in the dash compartment or handlebar bag. The car fob is great and smaller than the door remote/key combo I’d carried for years. If you had to have a key, the older Lexus keys were pretty slick with small buttons right on the key.
 

Amos Malone

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 15, 2022
Member Number
1073
Posts
152
Location
Europe
I don't know what will happen when the bike is 10 years old, for now I prefer the fob. Never have to take the gloves off because I forgot to put the key in the ignition before putting them on. Never break the key in the ignition. Never forget to remove the key from the bike when I park it. The key just sits in the pocket of my jacket and it all works without issues.
 
Last edited:

Chickenstrip

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
303
Posts
249
Location
NYC
I voted fob ... not that it's gonna matter much for this poor SOB. :lol3
 

outofstep

Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Member Number
1330
Posts
11
Location
BUCKHORN, KENTUCKY USA
When a FOB is lost does the bike still need to go to the dealer to program a new one?

Does a FOB still need a battery every year? I have metal keys that are decades old and still work fine.

Are there still problems with thieves hacking the so called keyless systems? And for semantics, isn't the FOB really an electronic key?

Can suckers that use a FOB buy a generic on Amazon or EBAY?

For the slow witted that last question might give you a clue as to how I feel about them. And I have owned bikes with the electronic keys. Fortunately I got rid of them.
 

Tripped1

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 10, 2022
Member Number
1276
Posts
88
Location
Land of Endless Summer
When a FOB is lost does the bike still need to go to the dealer to program a new one?

Does a FOB still need a battery every year? I have metal keys that are decades old and still work fine.

Are there still problems with thieves hacking the so called keyless systems? And for semantics, isn't the FOB really an electronic key?

Can suckers that use a FOB buy a generic on Amazon or EBAY?

For the slow witted that last question might give you a clue as to how I feel about them. And I have owned bikes with the electronic keys. Fortunately I got rid of them.

Doesn't matter because anymore even the keys have the exact type of RFID chips in them, and if you don't get them programmed (yes at the dealer) the key won't work anyway.....and there are failures that make the ECU loose the key encoding so you have to start over.

So the key is just an added step to starting the bike. That is if you want to ride bikes made after 2005 or so.
 

Expat47

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 5, 2022
Member Number
1263
Posts
47
Location
Athens, Greece
The fob on my Kymco AK550 is, admittedly, smaller than a bread basket but way too big for a pants pocket so it resides on a clip hanging off a belt loop.
Actually, this one is a replacement €1,000 replacement for the original I lost.

Oh, I'd prefer a key or, at least, a sensible fob.
 

Top Bottom