What's new
  • If you don't frequent the chat forum, make sure you read this post regarding land usage. It would be great if we could get everybody to send a comment in before Oct 7th!

The Lathe thread.

matty

Border raider.
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
139
Posts
265
Location
England Scotish border
Talk Lathes and anything about them, tell us what you got or what you want and share advice on operation/ procedure and general advice. .
 

Provience

All bikes are dirt bikes
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
180
Posts
28
Location
N America
Turning is the art of the gods.

Mills and torches are for heathens!

Measure regularly, adjust as needed. That's about all the advice I've got at the moment. If you are taking spring passes before measuring your final part, take a spring pass before you measure on your way there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MVI

matty

Border raider.
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
139
Posts
265
Location
England Scotish border
I have three lathes myself, a Colchester Triumph 71/2 (This lathe is branded a clausing 15 in the states AFAIK Guess usa type marketing likes bigger numbers going with the diameter not the radius.).
I have a EX WW2 Lease lend (still with the little metal plaque stating as such), Hendey 1230 gearhead , and a small very beat up Myford ML4 that i have on a wooden railway sleeper bench in a back shed.
 

MVI

MVI MOTO
Mod
Vendor
ADV+
Joined
Feb 2, 2022
Member Number
14
Posts
2,490
Location
NRH, TX
Considering a PALMGREN 9680213 or 9684520 for home use. PRO's or CON's with this brand? Even the Dayton's are Made in China now.


1644412908383.png
 
Last edited:

Provience

All bikes are dirt bikes
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
180
Posts
28
Location
N America
I know a couple people with the bench top little Chinese lathes and they are happy with them, mostly doing small gun parts and such. Biggest thing is the small thru bores, but really "what are you doing with it" is the bigger issue. Good tooling can make up for lack of power to a certain extent. Just for doing bushings I'd imagine it would do good.

As a bigot, I'm not a fan of multi purpose lathe mill combos or mill drill combos, or even combo welders, but that just me. I'd like to have a bench top unit though.

A good sturdy table/bench/base will go a long way. Cheap lathes have cheap frames, cheap frames can will and do flex and will cause problems. Lathes like to be and stay square with the rails.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MVI

Punkinhead

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
105
Posts
142
Location
Land of Walmart Shoppers
People do amazing things with those little combo units but they're definitely a compromise. Do you have space constraints? If space isn't an issue I'd go with a separate lathe and knee mill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MVI

MVI

MVI MOTO
Mod
Vendor
ADV+
Joined
Feb 2, 2022
Member Number
14
Posts
2,490
Location
NRH, TX
Space is at a premium in our welding shop, and with Several MIG, TIG and Plasma units we just dont have space for both a mill and a lathe.
The largest part I can see machining is a hub for a 1 Ton 4x4.

I prefer the 11" x 27" over the 9" x 20" for that reason
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
152
Posts
16
Location
Wi
I love machine work!!

I have a 14/40 clausing copy and a 16x60 Dean Smith and Grace beast.

I’ll look forward to see your guys setups!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MVI

matty

Border raider.
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
139
Posts
265
Location
England Scotish border
Friends i know have EMCO / hobymat small lathes, another has a similar lathe called an Axminster , and to be fair they do some good work on them. we are currently living in rather an expensive time, cars bikes property is over priced and lathes and machinery generally are no exception.
Its possible to find older lathes, but they are not as plentiful and as economical to buy as they once were, so the Chinese clarkes etc are an option many will consider and for good reason.
My advice for what its worth is to look carefully at any used examples you might find on the sales rooms online auctions or selling sites, research the brand and model look at similar models and what they made at auctions and draw your own conclusions on what you think its worth, decide a max price go up to that and don't get sucked into the bidding melee sadly all too common at auctions in these post covid19 times.
A good site for doing any research on the vast majority of lathes is this one( http://www.lathes.co.uk/ ) lots of brands model info and general specifications to help you decide on a used lathe if you do decide to go down that route.
 

Provience

All bikes are dirt bikes
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
180
Posts
28
Location
N America
Space is at a premium in our welding shop, and with Several MIG, TIG and Plasma units we just dont have space for both a mill and a lathe.
The largest part I can see machining is a hub for a 1 Ton 4x4.

I prefer the 11" x 27" over the 9" x 20" for that reason
100% my honest opinion, I don't see much use for a mill in a welding shop. Biggest lathe you can fit, plasma table, bandsaw, even a portable with a table, standalone drill press (easy to move) and a big press/brake/Ironworker would all be my want to have before worrying about a mill.

How much parts do you need to mill out that wouldn't be better cut and folder/welded out of plate?

Auto hubs should all cut pretty good and without much effort, holding them may be a pain, but anything over 10" swing should do it. I'd much, much rather turn the bores on a latge rather than bore them with a mill.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
152
Posts
16
Location
Wi
100% my honest opinion, I don't see much use for a mill in a welding shop. Biggest lathe you can fit, plasma table, bandsaw, even a portable with a table, standalone drill press (easy to move) and a big press/brake/Ironworker would all be my want to have before worrying about a mill.

How much parts do you need to mill out that wouldn't be better cut and folder/welded out of plate?

Auto hubs should all cut pretty good and without much effort, holding them may be a pain, but anything over 10" swing should do it. I'd much, much rather turn the bores on a latge rather than bore them with a mill.
In the perfect world You need a mill also. The ability to locate and drill accurate holes is priceless. I have been pining over getting a haas vf3 or vf4 for my shop.
 

Provience

All bikes are dirt bikes
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
180
Posts
28
Location
N America
In the perfect world You need a mill also. The ability to locate and drill accurate holes is priceless. I have been pining over getting a haas vf3 or vf4 for my shop.
Layout die and a sharp stick are handy and make it easy to eyeball. I can certainly see the benefit, I've got 4 mills and 3 lathes at work, but for the automotive and welding stuff 2d flatwork and turning take the bulk of it.

Actually have a haas vf2, wanted and asked for a 3, work said no, have a 2 🤣

Did a 14.5" square part the other day on a haas tm2, only has 12" y travel. Made for a bear to setup over and over, but it certainly worked.

In a perfect world you aren't pressed for space. That's (part of) my gripe about the small and combo mills is that they just lack the table and travel. At least with a freestanding drill press you get a ton of throat, often more quill travel and can setup in whatever odd way works. Unless I'm doing small /6" Dia hole patterns it will be getting eyeballed and laid out regardless.

Don't let me stop you from spending your money though, buy as much as you can afford. I'll take a week off work to play...er, setup it for you!
 
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
152
Posts
16
Location
Wi
Layout die and a sharp stick are handy and make it easy to eyeball. I can certainly see the benefit, I've got 4 mills and 3 lathes at work, but for the automotive and welding stuff 2d flatwork and turning take the bulk of it.

Actually have a haas vf2, wanted and asked for a 3, work said no, have a 2 🤣

Did a 14.5" square part the other day on a haas tm2, only has 12" y travel. Made for a bear to setup over and over, but it certainly worked.

In a perfect world you aren't pressed for space. That's (part of) my gripe about the small and combo mills is that they just lack the table and travel. At least with a freestanding drill press you get a ton of throat, often more quill travel and can setup in whatever odd way works. Unless I'm doing small /6" Dia hole patterns it will be getting eyeballed and laid out regardless.

Don't let me stop you from spending your money though, buy as much as you can afford. I'll take a week off work to play...er, setup it for you!
Does any of your machines have probing/ tool setting on them? I want to find one that has that to help speed up repair work.
 

MVI

MVI MOTO
Mod
Vendor
ADV+
Joined
Feb 2, 2022
Member Number
14
Posts
2,490
Location
NRH, TX
100% my honest opinion, I don't see much use for a mill in a welding shop. Biggest lathe you can fit, plasma table, bandsaw, even a portable with a table, standalone drill press (easy to move) and a big press/brake/Ironworker would all be my want to have before worrying about a mill.

How much parts do you need to mill out that wouldn't be better cut and folder/welded out of plate?

Auto hubs should all cut pretty good and without much effort, holding them may be a pain, but anything over 10" swing should do it. I'd much, much rather turn the bores on a latge rather than bore them with a mill.


The Mill would more of a luxury for small jobs, cutting dovetails and such. Not realted to the welding business per se.
 

Provience

All bikes are dirt bikes
Joined
Feb 8, 2022
Member Number
180
Posts
28
Location
N America
Does any of your machines have probing/ tool setting on them? I want to find one that has that to help speed up repair work.
Vf2 does, it's a neat tool and worth whatever it costs.

Need to have? No. Nice to have? Yes. I'll take a probe over chip auger every day though.
 

tubebender

Orange Koolaid Drinker
Joined
Feb 10, 2022
Member Number
575
Posts
35
Location
Oceanside CA
I'm not real good at machining, but I've used lathes and mills for personal and work projects.
I had my Dad's old Atlas 618, the lathe I learned on, for a couple of years. It was pretty beat up by then, and I let it go.
I really regret that I did that.

Currently, I have one of those older Chinese combo units. It's the biggest POS I've ever used, but it was free.
There is no way to use the mill head without stacking the work up about 8 - 12 inches.
At least I can turn the odd bushing or drill a hole.
 

CDN Rick

Canoodia Eh?
ADV+
Joined
Feb 2, 2022
Member Number
12
Posts
1,945
Location
Niagara, Canada
100% my honest opinion, I don't see much use for a mill in a welding shop. Biggest lathe you can fit, plasma table, bandsaw, even a portable with a table, standalone drill press (easy to move) and a big press/brake/Ironworker would all be my want to have before worrying about a mill.

How much parts do you need to mill out that wouldn't be better cut and folder/welded out of plate?

Auto hubs should all cut pretty good and without much effort, holding them may be a pain, but anything over 10" swing should do it. I'd much, much rather turn the bores on a latge rather than bore them with a mill.

I agree. There is very little a mill can do, that a lathe cannot also do with some well thought out setups.
If you can only have one, definitely get the lathe. And get the biggest lathe you can afford/fit. There is simply no replacement for displacement with a lathe. The more metal in it, and the more horsepower, the more you will be able to do. Big lathes can make tiny parts, but small lathes can’t make big parts.
 

CDN Rick

Canoodia Eh?
ADV+
Joined
Feb 2, 2022
Member Number
12
Posts
1,945
Location
Niagara, Canada
I don’t have tons of shop space, but this Emco Maximat MQ3100 with a Maximat7 millhead is everything I need and more.

10” swing, 1hp on 110v power lathe and 1/4hp 1740rpm mill will do almost anything I need for a bike.

Austrian made in the 60’s and 70’s. It’s much heavier than it’s current Chinese counterparts.

75117A5B-0C2F-4D32-B8AC-BD0275BDD7EB.jpeg
 

Top Bottom